Translate this page
Report details abuses at multiple California rehab centers
Report details abuses at multiple California rehab centers

Report details abuses at multiple California rehab centers

Friday, June 20th, 2014
Issue 25, Volume 18.
Alex Groves
Staff Writer

Every day millions of Americans wake up dealing with an addiction problem. Approximately 23.5 million people needed treatment for an illicit drug or alcohol abuse problem in the year 2009 alone, according to Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administrationís (SAMHSAís) National Survey on Drug Use and Health.

However, addiction isnít limited to substances that are illicit. Prescription painkillers or any number of substances that impact the way the human body functions can be abused and can gain an addictive hold over the people that use them.

Each and every day many of the individuals who suffer from current substance abuse problems will attempt to kick the habit for good; theyíll go to a rehab treatment facility in the hopes that it will give them the ability to overcome their dependence on a substance. That dependence in many cases isnít just mental, but also physical.

Detoxification, or the process by which a drug leaves the body, can be a key example of that. People who actively and habitually use opioids at the time of their check-in at a rehab facility could begin to experience agitation, anxiety and severe muscle aches among a number of other withdrawal symptoms, according to studies by the National Institutes of Health (NIH).

People who suffer from addictions to alcohol also suffer from an array of symptoms that includes seizure, rapid heart rate and fever, according to officials.

Some specialists in Southwest Riverside say these withdrawal symptoms can be deadly when paired with an extenuating illness or disorder, especially in facilities where medical staff arenít present on a regular basis.

Locally, and in California as a whole, there have been a number of deaths at rehab facilities that took in individuals trying to get themselves clean of a particular substance.

There was Brandon Jacques, a Missouri resident, who came to an Orange County rehabilitation center after developing an eating disorder and an addiction to alcohol. The facility failed to transfer him to a hospital immediately after lab testing indicated his electrolytes were out of balance. He would later die of cardiac arrest attempting to do 30 pushups.

Gary Benefield of Arizona was another out of state resident who came to California seeking treatment for his alcohol addiction. He came to the state in spite of a recent bout of pneumonia and a case of COPD (chronic obstructive pulmonary disease), and he flew on a plane without the oxygen he was dependent on.

Benefield complained of being in pain and being disoriented before and after his arrival to A Better Tomorrow Treatment Center (ABTTC) in Murrieta.

Staff at the treatment facility gave Benefield medication even though they didnít have the medical authority to do so. They gave him antidepressants to calm his mood, medications known to have an inhibitory effect on oneís lung function.

The next morning, on what was supposed to be his 53rd birthday, Benefield was found slumped over on the floor dead.

Another case involving multiple individuals was that of Dr. Jerry Rand of Bay Recovery in San Diego, who frequently found himself in question before the Medical Board of California.

The board alleged that Rand was engaged in the practice of polypharmacy, prescribing multiple medications to patients without regard to how those medications might interact with one another.

In 2009, a 29-year-old female patient of Randís was found drowned inside a bathtub, something the medical board once again linked to Randís alleged practice of keeping his patients overmedicated.

All of those cases and more are documented in a California Senate Office of Oversight Advertisement
Advertisement for Berry-Bell and Hall Mortuary
[ Berry-Bell and Hall Mortuary ]
and Outcomes report from September 4, 2012. The report lists a number of cases that show a history of unusual and sometimes illegal operations at rehabilitation facilities across the state.

Sharin Safarty, a prevention specialist and owner of Addiction Recovery Center in Temecula, believes the problem is that many individuals and their families are desperate to find help; in their desperation these individuals donít think to ask what proportion of care is provided by medical professionals as opposed to certified counselors or interns.

She said many facilities have doctors who may be on staff but these doctors are not a force present at the facilities all the time. Sometimes a doctor may be associated with the facility in some capacity or another, but that doesnít mean he checks up on patients regularly.

This lays the ground work for undiagnosed issues and tragic results, according to Safarty.

The end result is that the counselors and interns are often left to their own devices when a patient is suffering from an illness that requires medication. Theyíre the ones that have to make the tough decisions about medication disbursement and the immediate management of physical or psychological emergencies, she said.

Safarty said that families of potential patients should verify that those patients are going to a 24/7 medical facility for treatment if their primary goal is detox only.

She added that only when a potential patient has detoxed and been thoroughly assessed for potential co-occurring disorders can they can make the choice between a system where there is moral support (such as one of the previously mentioned live-in facilities) or a more comprehensive treatment.

Safarty recommends the latter of the two for people who have a co-occurring condition that needs to be medicated such as bi-polar disorder or depression.

The prevention specialist said she refers all potential patients to fully-staffed medical treatment centers when they need to detox.

"We find and set patients up at appropriate certified medical facilities because thatís where they need to go find the care they need," Safarty said.

A local drug addiction specialist, who wished to remain anonymous, said one of the problems is that many of the rehabs that arenít based in certified medical facilities donít refer patients when they need to. Theyíll try to hold on to their patients, even when the signs indicate they shouldnít.

Theyíll accept patients when they shouldnít and then will be reluctant to send them on to other facilities to receive more comprehensive care or care specifically geared toward their detox needs or any other medical needs they may have.

He said some local facilities even go as far as lying to potential patients to get them to check in. And when patients arrive, they find a much starker reality than the one they were promised.

"They were going into these places and making promises to people that there would be swimming pools, horses and all these things they were going to get," he said. "And they get here and none of them are here; they were lied to."

He said he hopes there will be reform among rehab centers that bill themselves as medical facilities when that isnít actually the case. He said rehab centers must be prepared to represent themselves in an honest way and must be prepared to treat their clients with proper care.

However, he doesnít think thatís going to happen without the push of the public and attorneys.

"(We need) to put pressure on the people whose responsibility it is to do something about this," he said.



Comment Profile ImageMelanie
Comment #1 | Friday, Jun 27, 2014 at 4:05 pm
It is a shame that this happens, but there are treatment facilities in existance that operate with ethics and morals that focus on client care first. I am proud to be employed by one of those facilities and I work with a physician who is available to our client's 24/7. When a client requires a higher level of care, we refer them immediately. I am a substance abuse counselor, and I am proud of the work I do every day.
Comment Profile ImageBuck
Comment #2 | Sunday, Jun 29, 2014 at 8:38 am
The problem is that there is no way for a potential patient or family member to discern between quality (appropriate) programs and those who are only interested in separating you from your money. The first layer, state licensing or certification is underfunded and a miserable failure. The next layer, accreditation, (CARF, JCAHO etc. mostly CARF) are interested in maintaining their numbers ($). CARF will tell you that they aren't interested in accountability of their members, that is up to the state. How convenient.
Last week I heard an MFT talk about how proud of her employer she is, despite the fact that they have had six deaths in their facility that have resulted in multiple wrongful death lawsuits. Is that naivite or just greed because she makes so much for supervising four interns that the program pays nothing.
It is more than a shame, it is a crime when treatment programs rely on salespeople in their call centers to lie to people about the medical backgrounds of their staff and their lie results in the patient's death.
Kudos to your e-mag for calling attention to the multitude of problems the beset some of our largest, most "prestigious" programs. Sober living is not for detox. Let's do away with the "Florida Model" and implement the ASAM patient placement criteria before another patient loses their life instead of reaping the promises of recovery!!
Comment Profile ImageAndrea
Comment #3 | Monday, Jun 30, 2014 at 6:55 pm
I'm glad to see that these tragedies are finally getting some attention. I have heard too many stories of deaths in treatment centers that could have been prevented. It surprises me that Temecula hasn't run a story on this a long time ago with the amount of deaths in this area alone. The people who are responsible need to be exposed, I'm happy to see its happening.

Article Comments are contributed by our readers, and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Valley News staff. The name listed as the author for comments cannot be verified; Comment authors are not guaranteed to be who they claim they are.


Add your Comment


Images, Formatting, or HTML is not allowed : plain text only. You may post up to 5 website addresses within your comment.


The Valley News has tightened its' policy regarding comments.
While we invite you to contribute your opinions and thoughts, we request that you refrain from using vulgar or obscene words and post only comments that directly pertain to the specific topic of the story or article.
Comments that are derogatory in nature have a high likelihood for editing or non-approval if they carry the possibility of being libelous.
The comment system is not intended as a forum for individuals or groups to air personal grievances against other individuals or groups.
Please, no advertising or trolling.
In posting a comment for consideration, users understand that their posts may be edited as necessary to meet system parameters, or the post may not be approved at all. By submitting a comment, you agree to all the rules and guidelines described here.
Most comments are approved or disregarded within one business day.

RSS FeedFacebookTwitter

Advertisement for Crown Hill Pizza


Most Commented

Reach Local Customers

The Valley News The Valley News
760-723-7319 - 1588 S. Mission Rd. Suite 200, Fallbrook CA 92028
All contents copyright ©2015
About Us
Earthquake Information
Business Listings
Contact Us
Letter to the Editor
Report a website error
Online Digital Edition
RSS Feeds